Skip to main content

An SEO agency for Columbus small businesses

Checking your listing after every change of hours and asking for reviews when you remember are jobs you can hand over. We do them for Columbus businesses and report in plain words each month.

How search works in Columbus

Somebody new to Dublin has no dentist, no mechanic and no plumber. When a tooth aches or a drain backs up they have no neighbor to ask, so they search, and they may add the name of their town. What they want is modest: a business that plainly works in Dublin and not only somewhere in Columbus, something other customers wrote, and hours and a phone number that are right when they call. A newcomer in Westerville, Grove City or Pickerington wants the same, under the name of a different town.

The business they are looking for may be a dental practice in Hilliard or a repair shop in Gahanna that has always lived on being known. A newcomer does not know it, so we build what that newcomer reads. They land on a page for their own town that describes work done there. They see a listing with the right name, address, hours and phone number, which we keep accurate when you add a location in Delaware County. They read reviews, because after each job the customer is asked for one. Which towns get a page is your decision. We check every page ourselves and send it to you before it goes live; how closely you read it is up to you. Each month we report the searches you appeared for, the visits and the inquiries. SEO starts at $1,100 a month, and we do not promise a position.

A plumber in Pickerington who wants more work would look to Lancaster first. A resident there who searches for a plumber can find a page with Lancaster in its name and, once there is one, a job done on a Lancaster street. Our work gives the plumber that page. The van and the premises in Pickerington stay as they are. After Lancaster comes whichever place the work points to, Marysville, Mansfield or Dayton, each reached the same way. We know because we did it in this state: a site we built for one of our own businesses, covering Michigan and Ohio, brought it more than $100,000 in additional revenue in under six months, and work as far away as Oklahoma.

What you receive

  • Technical foundations: speed, structure, titles and what search engines can reach.
  • Service and location pages and blog posts written for your customers' searches.
  • A newsletter to your own list, built from the month's work.
  • A plain monthly report on searches, visits and inquiries.

How it runs

  • We find what stops the site being found and fix it.
  • We build the pages buyers are looking for.
  • We report what happened in plain terms each month, and what comes next.
Everything that is included

Scope and investment

Prices in US dollars (USD)

  • Smaller SEO engagement$1,100 a month
  • Standard SEO engagement$1,850 a month
  • Expanded SEO engagementFrom $3,350 a month

Three months to start, then month to month with 30 days' notice. We do not promise a position. Newsletters go to your own list from your own email account. Paid ads, site rebuilds and translation are separate.

Work you can inspect

The Tucker CPA website home page, built by Butler Agency

Tucker CPA

We built the brand, the website and a national content system for a new CPA firm, and we handle its SEO.

Read the case study
The Beyond the Bedside Foundation website home page, built by Butler Agency

Beyond the Bedside Foundation

A website for a new children’s foundation, built for families, student volunteers and supporters.

Read the case study

Questions before we start

We are opening a second location in Delaware County. What should we do first?

Create its listing with the exact name, address, hours and phone number before it opens, and a page on the site for that location. Then ask the first customers there for reviews on that listing, not the original one.

Do people in Dublin or Hilliard type the name of their town, or just Columbus?

The monthly report can answer that for your own business. We list the searches that brought visitors each month, so you can see whether names such as Dublin, Hilliard or Gahanna are in them. That list tells us which pages to write next.

We are known in German Village. How do we reach the suburbs?

With proof of work there. A page for Dublin needs jobs you did in Dublin, how long it takes you to get there and who answers. If you have not worked there yet, we say you serve it and add the proof as it comes.

What would you like your business to do next?

Tell us where the work gets stuck or where you want to grow. We will help you choose a practical first step.

Discuss your project