Skip to main content

Guide

Why your cyber insurance answers have to be true

A cyber insurance application isn't a survey. The person who signs it says the answers are true and complete, and insurers say they rely on those answers to decide whether to cover you and at what price. When an answer turns out to be wrong, the coverage you have been paying for may not be there when you need it.

This guide explains how that happens, the case most often cited, and why the rules depend on your state. It isn't legal advice: what applies to your policy is a question for your broker or lawyer.

All resources

Denial, or a policy that never existed

  • A denied claim. The insurer pays nothing for this loss, often pointing to a condition or exclusion in the policy.
  • Rescission. The insurer treats the whole policy as void from the start, usually because of a misstatement on the application. The premium is returned, and every claim under it is treated as uncovered.

Commentators also describe "post-loss underwriting": an insurer looking closely at the application only after a large claim comes in. The answers you give at renewal can be read again on the worst day of your year.

Travelers and the multi-factor answer

In 2022, Travelers asked a federal court in Illinois to rescind a cyber policy it had issued to a manufacturer that had suffered a ransomware attack. Travelers alleged that the company's application and a signed attestation said multi-factor authentication was in use, when, according to Travelers, it protected only the firewall and not the server. In August 2022 the parties filed an agreed stipulation, and the court entered an order declaring the policy void from the start.

That was one agreed order, and the facts about multi-factor authentication were allegations. It doesn't show what every insurer or court would do. It does show how one answer about one control became the whole dispute.

Not every wrong answer has the same effect

States set different tests for when a misstatement can void a policy. Three examples:

  • Massachusetts: a misstatement doesn't void a policy unless it was made with intent to deceive or it increased the risk of loss (General Laws c.175, s.186).
  • New York: a misrepresentation voids a policy only if it was material, meaning the insurer would have refused the policy had it known the truth (Insurance Law s.3105).
  • Michigan: in a 2019 case about a tavern's property policy, the Court of Appeals held a misstatement material because the insurer's underwriting rules would have barred coverage.

Which rule applies to your policy, and how, depends on your state and your policy's wording. Your broker or lawyer can tell you.

Before you tick yes

  • Every place the question says. "All users" means all of them, including the old shared account.
  • Now, not planned. A control you intend to turn on next month isn't in place today.
  • Checked, not remembered. Look at the setting, or ask someone who can show you.
  • Written down. Keep a dated record of what you checked and what you found.

If a control isn't fully in place, say so accurately and talk to your broker before you sign. Many gaps take hours, not months, to fix.

When things change

New staff, new computers, a new email or backup provider: each can change whether last year's answers are still true. Ask your broker whether your policy expects you to report changes, and keep your own record current either way.

Want your answers checked before you sign?

We review the security questions on your application against how your systems are actually set up, fix agreed gaps, and give you dated evidence to take to your broker. Done remotely, from $995.